Showing posts with label processes. Show all posts
Showing posts with label processes. Show all posts

Wednesday, 13 November 2013

Overview of IPCC 2013, Chapter 12 - Long-term Climate Change: Projections, Commitments and Irreversibility

Previously, the IPCC have been hesitant to use the term “tipping point”, possibly in reluctance to cause mass hysteria amongst the Daily Mail and similar. Even their most recent report doesn't feature tipping points strongly, though closer inspection reveals more. Their 2013 report details combined evidence from many of the best respected climate scientists to show that tipping points, or at least alternative stable states, do exist in a variety of forms, a few of which are discussed here.

The September 2013 report defines a tipping point as “a perturbed state irreversible on a given timescale if the recovery timescale from this state due to natural processes is significantly longer than the time it takes for the system to reach this perturbed state.” The Earth system has multiple and varied response timescales to climate changes. For a rapid change in forcing, much of the surface temperature response will be evident within decades. Taking that view, most aspects of the climate change resulting from CO2 emissions are irreversible due to the long residence time of CO2 in the atmosphere and the resulting warming (Solomon et al., 2009).

A number of components of Earth’s system have been proposed as possessing critical thresholds or tipping points, beyond which abrupt transitions to an alternative state result. It is important to note that abrupt changes that arise from nonlinearities within the climate system are intrinsically difficult to assess and timing of future changes difficult to predict, making mitigation difficult. This table shows some of the potential climate tipping points identified by the IPCC report.
 ARCTIC OCEAN
There is very little evidence in climate models of a tipping point from perennially ice-covered Arctic ocean to a seasonally ice-free Ocean where further ice loss in unstoppable. It is, however, very likely that Arctic sea ice will continue shrinking and thinning during the 21st century as global mean surface temperature rises. Conversely, it has been suggested by models that the surface mass balance of the Antarctic Ice Sheet may increase because increased snowfall rates outweigh melt increase. These abrupt changes in ice volume do not necessarily require the existence of a tipping point in the system. Irreversibility of ice sheet volume and extent changes can occur when a decreased elevation of the ice sheet induces a decreased surface mass balance, generally through increased melting.

ATLANTIC MERIDIONAL OVERTURNING CIRCULATION
Observations and models suggest that the present day ocean is already in a bi-stable regime, thereby allowing for multiple equilibria and a stable ‘off’ state of the Atlantic MOC (Bryden et al., 2011; Hawkins et al., 2011). It is very likely that the AMOC will weaken, but confidence in the magnitude of this is low, and crossing a tipping point similar to that of the Younger Dryas cooling is very unlikely in the next century or so.

INDIAN MONSOON
Studies with conceptual models (Zickfeld et al., 2005; Levermann et al., 2009) show that the Indian summer monsoon can operate in two stable regimes. Besides the “wet” summer monsoon, there is a stable state characterized by low precipitation over India. This suggests that any perturbation of the radiative budget that often weakens the pressure gradient could induce abrupt transitions between these two regimes.

So, there it is, there’s no denying that tipping points exist. The main point to take from this is that these changes are unpredictable in scale and in feedback response, and that most of the bigger climatic changes are unlikely to happen in the near future.


CLIMATE CHANGE 2013: THE PHYSICAL SCIENCEBASIS, Chapter 12, IPCC, 2013.  See full article for internal  references.)

Monday, 28 October 2013

Five Global Warming "Tipping Points"

This National Geographic article looks at 5 localities that are likely to change when we reach a tipping point relevant to that system, where crossing it would cause serious changes in some of Earth's system processes with knock-on effects on others. 
http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2009/03/photogalleries/tipping-points-climate-change/index.html 
1) Amazon basin
Firstly, the Amazon Basin, where climate shifts may lead to less rainfall,huge loss of species diversity which would damage the forest's regulation of air quality, fresh water cycle, and atmospheric circulation.


Secondly, disruption on the Atlantic Meridional overturning circulation, preventing warm water from moving north and having a dramatic impact on ocean and terrestrial ecosystems, as well as affecting global climatic circulation.

Thirdly, a warming of 4 degrees C would cause massive melting of the Greenland ice sheet. An ice-free Greenland would cause up to 6 to 7 meters of sea-level rise, threatening up to 300 million people, as well as ecosystems, with harmful floods.


Fourth, some have suggested that the El Nino periodic shift in condition of the ocean and atmosphere in the tropical Pacific may become an almost permanent state, causing severe drought in Southeast Asia and the Amazon Basin and increased floods and changes in the marine food web along the South American Pacific coast.

Fifth, melting Antarctic ice could raise raise the world's sea level by up to 6 to 7 meters. The melting ice may reveal islands under the ice that are currently buried. Already fast moving ice streams have released large amounts of freshwater into surrounding oceans.

Friday, 25 October 2013

Planetary Boundaries and Tipping Points explained!

If you do any reading about "tipping points" you'll be bombarded with things like 'planetary boundaries', 'regime shifts', 'critical transitions' and just about every combination of these words. It can be a bit confusing! So I'm going to explain it in what I hope is a much clearer way....

Brook et al. (2013) describe the following:
· Planetary boundary: a concept developed to define a desired operating range for Earth-system features and processes. Crossing a boundary implies damage or loss of existing functions or services across the system.

· Regime shift: a large, relatively rapid reorganization of the state of an ecosystem that can be triggered by synergistic feedbacks. Regime shifts can result from crossing tipping points, and are often hard to anticipate and difficult to reverse.
· Tipping point: the critical point at which strong non-linearities appear in the relationship between ecosystem attributes and drivers; once a tipping point threshold is crossed, the change to a new state is typically rapid and might be irreversible or exhibit hysteresis.

Life on Earth has displayed abrupt and massive changes in the past, so we have no reason to expect that similar global regime shifts will not occur again. These shifts changed ecosystem dynamics worldwide by rising temperatures, changes in rainfall, retreat of polar ice and glaciers, and declining ocean pH amongst others, resulting in profound changes in ecosystem services, biodiversity, and aesthetic values. (Hughes et al. 2013). 

The problem is, not all these planetary boundaries and tipping points have been defined, and crossing these thresholds is unlikely to manifest as sudden and simultaneous collapses worldwide.What if we've already passed unrecognized and unanticipated tipping points as incremental changes accumulate, and are in a slow transition to a new regime? Once a transition occurs, it can be difficult or even impossible to return to the previous state (Barnosky et al, 2012).
This image from Barnosky et al (2012) shows a prediction of Earth ecosystem response as human population grows as does its impact on the environment. Here, the system crosses a tipping point and reaching an alternative stable state.

Human forcing includes transformation of 43% of land to agricultural or urban landscapes, with the remainder of natural landscapes broken up by roads. Even during the last global-scale critical transition, only 30% of Earth’s surface went from being covered by glacial ice to being ice free! Modelling suggests that for a third of Earth, plant species will not be able to migrate quick enough to keep up with climate change, and those that can will have to battle highly fragmented landscapes (Barnosky et al. 2012).


The scientific concept and potential policy implications of tipping points and their consequences have recently attracted considerable interest (Brook et al, 2013) and rightly so. Looking at past global-scale state shifts and the global forcings we continue to exert, suggests that another global-scale state shift is isn't far away, if it has not already begun (Barnosky et al, 2012). The extent and scale of human–biosphere interactions and disruption highlights the need to operate within safe planetary boundaries say Hughes et al, (2013). Regardless, we must address causes of human-driven global change and improve our management of the environment in order to prevent a global-scale state shift, or at least to monitor it as much as possible.

  • Barnosky, A., D., Et Al. (2012) “Approaching a state shift in Earth’s Biosphere” Nature, 486, 52-58
  • Brook, B.W. et al. (2013) Does the terrestrial biosphere have planetary tipping points? Trends Ecol. Evol. 28, 396–401
  • Hughes, T., P., S. Carpenter, J. Rockstrom, M. Scheffer, and B. Walker (2013) “Multiscale regime shifts and planetary boundaries” Trends in Ecology & Evolution , 28, 7